All posts in Supreme Court

What will SCOTUS decide about 1129(a)(2)(A)(iii)? Not always a right to credit bid

In December, SCOTUS agreed to hear a 7th Circuit case, RadLAX Gateway Hotel, LLC v. Amalgamated Bank, on whether a secured creditor can be denied a right to credit bid its note when a debtor sells its collateral, pre-confirmation, pursuant to a plan.  The issue arises when a court is evaluating whether a plan satisfies the “fair and equitable” requirement for cram down on non-consenting impaired classes of secured claims, under an 1129(b).  1129(b)(2)(A) provides a set of three disjunctive descriptions of how a plan can provide secured claims with fair and equitable treatment, (i), (iii), or (iii).

The first prong involves either transfer of collateral or use by the debtor whereby the secured creditor’s lien remains, and the creditor receives a cash stream with present value of at least the collateral value and payments totaling the claim. Read more…

From Aki Koyama re: Chapter 13 Commitment Period

From Aki Koyama from Ms. Dockery’s office –

It appears that SCOTUS has denied cert for In re Baud which would have presented the fundamental issue of whether or not the Applicable Commitment Period is purely an independent, temporal measurement squarely before the Justices.  This breathes new life into the appeals set to be heard before the 9th Circuit to reexamine this issue in light of their prior holding in Kagenveama.

Currently, three appeals regarding the Applicable Commitment Period are pending before the 9th Circuit and one new appeal, Reed out of Oregon, is before the 9th Circuit BAP.  Hopefully, we will have an answer to this issue in 2012.  The three cases are In  re Henderson (the Idaho case and the appeal filed by the chapter 13 Trustee); In re Henderson (the same Idaho case but the appeal was filed by a creditor); In re Flores (this is the appeal with Borowitz & Clark and Rod Danielson).

Supreme Court Annual Report for 2011

Chief Justice John Roberts has issued the court’s annual report for 2011.  You can read it here